It’s that time of year again, the annual Holiday Eat-a-thon that starts on or about Thanksgiving Day and doesn’t end until the Super Bowl: turkey with all the trimmings to pizza, chicken wings, and chips and dip, along with the usual libations. Last year was the Postprandial Turkey Trot.

Turkey Trots, held all over the country, are merely excuses to gorge later that day.

I prefer a different kind of turkey trot: the one that bestows the Most Fowl Awards on those judges and lawyers who should not receive any pardons (presidential or otherwise) for their antics this year that made mere mortals (aka not lawyers or  judges) hold us in even less repute than we already are. We may scrape the bottom of “most trusted,” but we are not in the “least trusted.” At least, not yet.

This year, as last year, the buffet table is brimming with possible recipients for Most Fowl. So, where else to start but in California? A Los Angeles  Superior Court judge has been booted off the bench by the Judicial Performance Commission. Read all about it in this New York Post article. (It must have been a slow news day.) Here’s the commission’s decision, if you want to get into the weeds.  

The commission ordered Judge Robert Draper off the bench for a variety of willful and prejudicial misconduct. It found that Draper was either unfamiliar with ethical precepts or unwilling to conform to those standards. Even worse, Draper failed to cooperate with the commission’s investigation, refused to accept responsibility for his misconduct and lacked insight or remorse The commission found instances where Draper showed “a lack  of candor” during his testimony. Is “lack of candor” a polite way of saying “liar, liar, pants on fire?” However, the booting is anti-climactic, since Draper lost his bid for re-election this past June and will be gone in January. He wins the Judicial Most Fowl Award.

So many lawyers are doing excellent jobs as turkeys this season that it’s not easy to choose those appropriate for the award, but I think that the Lawyer(s) Most Fowl Award should be shared by those attorneys in the U.S. Attorney’s offices, and not just in D.C. DOJ’s ineptness goes beyond the ordinary clowning around. Here are a few examples of why this year’s Most Fowl Award must be shared (now, children, don’t argue about the drumsticks.)  

How about the need to tell the truth (what a concept), especially when it’s an assistant U.S. attorney trying to dig himself out of the hole that he finds himself in. Telling the truth to a court the first time is always preferred because then you don’t have to remember what you said then and what you say now. How would you like to be barred from ever showing your face in a particular federal case because the federal judge thinks you violated Rule 11 and acted in bad faith? 

But it’s not just this one case. The federal judiciary is fed up with the DOJ’s high jinks (aka low jinks) in other cases as well: Being part of a government office where credibility is not assumed is not an office that ethical lawyers should choose. 

The current DOJ under Todd Blanche takes its order and cues from 47 (let’s not even discuss that issue) using the mantra of 47’s mentor, Roy Cohn: “attack, counterattack, and never apologize.”

In another case in the District Court of Rhode Island, the judge ripped the government a new one, writing that government’s representation was clearly misleading, if not utterly false.” Now that’s a benchslap! There’s more. How about the supervisory AUSA in New Jersey who insisted on speaking without filing a notice of appearance? The court told him in judicial speak to STFU, but the supervisor did not. The court made it clear that it was concerned about the leadership chaos in the New Jersey office. The New Jersey federal judge commented that the goodwill and credibility of the U.S. Attorney’s office, built up over decades, had now been trashed in a year. 

Every career prosecutor in every U.S. Attorney’s Office across the country should know how quickly reputations are destroyed and how quickly that’s happened, but some just can’t help themselves. So the Most Fowl Award for lawyers this year belongs to the Department of Justice and its minions. Birds of a feather flock together.


Jill Switzer has been an active member of the State Bar of California for over 40 years. She remembers practicing law in a kinder, gentler time. She’s had a diverse legal career, including stints as a deputy district attorney, a solo practice, and several senior in-house gigs. She now mediates full-time, which gives her the opportunity to see dinosaurs, millennials, and those in-between interact — it’s not always civil. You can reach her by email at oldladylawyer@gmail.com.

The post The Preprandial Turkey Trot appeared first on Above the Law.