Rugby has a dependency problem, and it sits in a booth with a headset, writes CLINTON VAN DER BERG.

On Friday night in Paris, the TMO was summoned several times in the Nations Championship match between France and the Springboks.

Did the ball bounce off Kalvin Gourgues’s face or his hands? Upstairs. Was Ethan Hooker’s slap-down deliberate? Upstairs. Was Kurt-Lee Arendse’s try legal? Upstairs, and chalked off.

Only Jasper Wiese’s head-high cleanout, a yellow turned red, genuinely demanded a second look. The rest was noise.

Every stoppage let the air out of a Test crackling with intensity. Momentum is rugby’s lifeblood, and it drains away at the replay screen while 80,000 fans turn into a jury, waiting to see whether they agree.

Here’s the thing. The referee is not an ornament. He is paid to see, to decide, to own the call. Instead, the TMO has become the easy out, the default button for every flicker of doubt.

Unsure? Press it. Worried about the crowd? Press it. Ag, let someone else carry the can.

It’s a rarity when a try isn’t referred. The whistle, the screen, the verdict, the restart, the broken rhythm. The TMO has become rugby’s load-shedding: just when the game is cooking, the lights go out. On and on it goes.

And the cruel irony? When it is genuinely needed, it goes missing. In Cardiff on Saturday, New Zealand were awarded a try (Peter Lakai) that was palpably short of the line. That was a moment begging for a second look. No one bothered.

Defenders will say the cameras get it right. Often they do. But accuracy isn’t the only currency. A Test that lurches from review to review has lost something no replay can restore: its heartbeat. And referees, shielded by the screen, never learn to trust their own eyes.

This is not a plea for the old days. The technology is brilliant, and when it polices foul play or genuine doubt over a grounding, it earns its keep.

World Rugby has had a TMO review under way since last year. It’s time it delivered. The outcome should be brutal in its simplicity: serious foul play, and tries only where there is clear, genuine doubt – and keep French TV directors a mile away from any such decision-making.

MORE: Champions Cup tackles French TV bias

Make the TMO speak when spoken to, and only when the answer is a matter of fact: a foot in touch, a ball grounded, a head struck. Everything else, the referee decides. He is the boss. Let him be.

Rugby is a dynamic game and must remain so. Protect that. Rugby lives on collision and flow, the break and the roar. Let the whistle go, let play carry on, and let the human in the middle own his decision.

That’s the contract. Time to get back to it.

Photo: David Winter/Gallo Images

The post Time to put TMO back in its box appeared first on SA Rugby magazine.